More strategy discussion...
The way I understand cultural trends, isn't America moving away from the countrified/southern/redneck loving/traditional/backwoods/Midwestern "values" culture? Aren't we moving towards a Will and Grace/college educated/tolerant/less patriotic culture? Whenever the Republicans decry all things intellectual or they scream about the snobbery or nuanced thought of liberals, they alienate intelligent conservatives (there are plenty out there). At the same time, whenever they abandon traditional conservative bedrock principles like fiscal restraint and foreign policy realism, they alienate more of these thoughtful conservatives. You saw it happen this year when virtually every center-right-leaning pundit endorsed Kerry or refused to endorse Bush.
If the GOP continues on this path, they'll soon be the minority party. You can't run against "condescending intellect" forever, can you?
I might be in the minority here, but I think the Democrats did what they had to do this year. The odds were stacked against them. We were at war. Any time we're at war, there are a certain amount of people who are highly susceptible to patriotic appeals and will respond by supporting the incumbent. We need to stay the course that the Bill Clinton and the DLC laid out. Arianna Huffington often complains that the party lacks bold ideas, but she makes the mistake of thinking that bold ideas are liberal ideas. In fact, the only bold ideas in this party are coming from the DLC.
We can take the tired liberal approach and continue to pander to teachers unions and seniors and refuse to offer any bold ideas on education policy or social security reform. Or we can try out bold DLC ideas like teacher merit pay and social security reform (with some experimentation with partial privatization). The liberals will cringe and whine and cling to the status quo, but that's why we'll feed them a likeable candidate: John Edwards.