Bush = CarterI feel like Bush was only elected because of Clinton's impeachment (much like Carter was only elected because of Nixon's resignation / Ford's subsequent pardon). Bush is likely to lose if he faces a credible candidate in 2004. Here's why:
1. Bush is a southerner. Imagine if the Republicans nominated someone from the Northeast or Midwest for President - they'd win in a landslide. Nominating a southerner is like nominating a northeastern Democrat - it doesn't make much sense when you look at the electoral map.
2. Despite the tide against the Clinton administration's supposed corruption, Bush was only able to eek out a small 1 vote win in the electoral college. Battleground states in the next election will be Iowa, Ohio, West Virginia, New Hampshire, New Mexico, Arizona, and Nevada. Previous battle ground states of Oregon, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Illinois have trended sharply towards the Democrats, while Florida, Missouri, Tennessee, and Arkansas have trended towards the Republicans. Most pundits have Florida and Missouri as tossup states, but I think they will go decisively to the Republicans. Likewise, most pundits have Arizona as a Republican leaning state, but I think its a tossup due to its growing Hispanic population, and Nevada has been tilting Democratic lately.
By my calculations, without the battle ground states, the score will be:
Democrat - 248
Bush - 234.
If I had to predict the 7 battleground states, I would predict that Bush would win Iowa, Arizona, and Nevada, while the Democrat would win Ohio, West Virginia, New Hampshire, and New Mexico. That puts the score at:
Democrat - 282
Bush - 256.
That's a close election. If you take all of the states that I label tossups and the states that I label "leaning Rep/Dem" (states like Florida) then here are the results:
Democrat - 172
Bush - 174.
That's with all of the sure fire states in each column. Keep in mind, that is AS OF RIGHT NOW, if the campaign started TODAY. Things could change, but right now I'm using today's framework to have some fun with hypotheticals.